Why do we dislike the word “censorship” and love the word “freedom?” There are certainly many answers to this question, but I think one aspect is that no one likes being forced to do anything – or told we can’t do an activity. Even when we know that some action is right or the even the best choice, we don’t want others coercing us. We want the freedom to choose it. Of course, this includes online surfing.
Check out these words from a recent Christian song by Jason Gray:
“Give me rules - I will break them. Give me lines - I will cross them. I need more than a truth to believe. I need a truth that lives, moves, and breathes - To sweep me off my feet.”
It shouldn’t be surprising when we revolt at online “censorship” – and not just for Christians in select third-world countries. Why?
Our sinful natures like to test boundaries. More than that, we want to volunteer and not be drafted into service. We love our freedoms and ability to choose. Anything else seems “un-American” and “un-Christian.”
True, we want to be “protected” and “kept safe.” However, if we are honest about accountability and transparency, we realize that one person’s filter is another person’s censorship. The words we use to describe online challenges and solutions are very important.
I’ve been managing technology staff for two decades in the public sector. More than that, I oversee the networks supporting tens of thousands of government customers who know right from wrong online. Still, they choose to do the wrong things fairly often. They regularly violate policies and procedure and more. They may even “mean well,” but surfing patterns can get out of control and staff need to be disciplined. The phrase "the road to hell is paved with good intentions" rings true.
Not to let my private sector colleagues off too easy – this is not just a government employee problem. It is just as bad or worse in the private sector and in homes across the world. (Yes, I know this from multiple, reliable sources.) I’ve also spoken at homeschool conferences and various churches to a variety of audiences regarding Christian online conduct. I have interacted with Mom’s and Dads, teens and kids, young and old. (You can see several of my presentations at: http://netsafetyresources.com/videos/ )
The simple truth is that people are struggling in cyberspace. More policies and workplace edicts will not solve this problem. (On the other hand, we do need clear, concise policies at work to articulate the appropriate ways to use new technologies like smart phones at work. We do need to hold staff accountable, which means we do need lines.) Still, this is only a part of the overall solution for Internet Safety at home and work. Rules and censorship alone will never work in the long run - since people will revolt.
Who is right?
So am I siding with the Internet Libertarians? Not fully. I think they underestimate the global problems and nature of the Internet. I believe our governments have important roles to play in stopping organized crime, enforcing laws and providing a safe, reliable online experience. However, I do think Libertarians correctly point out the limitations and over-reach that can occur with too much government intervention or on reliance in government.
Am I siding with Socialists who say this is all going to be fixed with more government intervention and controls? Not! Government can never solve this problem alone. Personal responsibility is paramount. But I do think that government can (and is) providing helpful online protections from online thieves, child molesters and Internet stalkers. There are global Internet problems that are much more complex than most people realize, and we need governments around the world working together to offer appropriate law enforcement on our digital highways and not just our physical highways (roads).
Do I side with the free-market entrepreneurs trying to offer packaged solutions that are easy to use? Yes, please send us more answers, better tools and technology to protect us and allow us to surf our values. Security and privacy online are growing problems, and we need new solutions. Still, technology alone will not solve this problem. There will always be ways to use technology for evil. (Remember that we've had bank robbers for hundreds of years despite new technology.)
Do I side with pastors who preach against cyber lust and other online sins? Yes again. As a Christian, I think that Internet conduct (or cyber ethics) begins as a heart issue. It starts with your worldview and authentic, Biblical values.
What do you really believe? Overcoming temptation must include a bottom-up process that starts with individuals. Few Internet or security “experts” in the field want to acknowledge this part of the problem.
Still, as a society, there are many aspects of online life that are out of control for well-meaning Christians who start off with their “hearts in the right place.” I have discussed cyber ethics and related Internet behaviors with several men who believe that Internet accountability and solutions regarding technology and process are overblown. They feel that if your heart is right, you don’t need anything else. They basically ignore the technology and process sides of the equation.
I disagree with this heart-only approach. Why? Verse four from the famous hymn “Come Thou Fount of Every Blessing” says it better than I can:
O to grace how great a debtor
Daily I’m constrained to be!
Let Thy goodness, like a fetter,
Bind my wandering heart to Thee.
Prone to wander, Lord, I feel it,
Prone to leave the God I love;
Here’s my heart, O take and seal it,
Seal it for Thy courts above.
Our hearts are prone to wander. We are sinners who are easily deceived. God has given us family and friends to help us overcome sinful habits. He has also given us technology to help – just as He has given us the Internet as a tool to get things done.
I've asked some of these men if they ever fall to temptation online? "Yes, but I just repent and move on."
I think this approach lacks the required depth of analysis and adequate protections to be successful (for the majority of people) in the long-run.
What to do?
OK, so what words can we use if we don’t want to say “censorship” or “Internet freedom?” I prefer “Opting-In to Online Integrity.” Or, Surf Your Values. We need to implement the Seven Habits of Online Integrity.
No doubt, some will think I am just pushing concepts in my book. However, Virtual Integrity is now out of print, and there is no personal financial gain for me to say these things. The truth is that I want to help your family achieve victory in this online battle that will last for the rest of our lives.
Bottom line - We need "all hands on deck" to solve these complex Internet problems. Avoid the extreme positions. Solutions require answers that cover people, processes and technology - together. Yes, that means government can help. But more importantly, churches, families and passionate individuals need to stay engaged and “work out your salvation with fear and trembling.”
On a personal level - we need new hearts, transformed lives. We need a Redeemer. Like Jason Gray sings, we need to “fall in love” with the right person – Jesus Christ. That will motivate change in our behaviors – including the processes and technology we use each and every day.
Our God is our creator who knows our needs – and our vulnerabilities. When we are tempted – there will be a way out. We also have a Savior who will forgive us when we turn our backs on Him, if we sincerely repent. Knowing God is life-changing – even in cyberspace.